Fidelity vs. TD Ameritrade: How the brokerages compare

Share to friends
Listen to this article

Insider’s consultants select the finest services and products to assist make sensible choices together with your cash (here’s how). In some circumstances, we obtain a fee from our our partners, nonetheless, our opinions are our personal. Terms apply to presents listed on this web page.

Fidelity vs. TD Ameritrade: The greatest variations

Fidelity and TD Ameritrade funding account are behemoths in relation to the on-line brokerage area. Both cater to a number of forms of traders, and each provide commission-free shares, ETFs, and choices. You may make the most of IRAs and copious funding sorts at both platform. 

However, Fidelity can be the best choice in the event you’re searching for the lowest charges. Its most simple automated investing account, Fidelity Go, features a fee-free possibility (i.e., you will pay $0 in advisory charges in the event you’ve obtained a stability decrease than $10,000, and — no matter account stability — you will not should account for expense ratios in the funds it makes use of). 

Its advisor-guided, automated account, Fidelity Personalized Planning & Advice, has a $25,000 minimal and 0.35% payment, however it additionally waives expense ratios, due to the Fidelity Flex mutual funds. TD Ameritrade’s managed accounts are now not accepting new shoppers, however the charges for these accounts exceeded that of Fidelity’s managed accounts anyway.

TD Ameritrade funding account has now merged lots of its merchandise with Charles Schwab’s (since Schwab acquired the brokerage), however it’s nonetheless the more sensible choice for buying and selling platforms, mutual funds, and futures buying and selling. 

Fidelity and TD Ameritrade funding account options and account choices additionally range.

Fidelity Investments 2x1 logo on Personal Finance Insider background.

td ameritrade logo on Personal Finance Insider post.

Account sorts

  • Individual and joint taxable brokerage accounts

  • Automated accounts

  • Individual retirement accounts (IRAs)

  • Annuities

  • Trusts

  • 529 plans

  • Managed accounts

  • HSAs

  • Custodial accounts

  • Margin accounts
  • Charitable

Account sorts

  • Individual and joint accounts

  • Individual retirement accounts (IRAs)

  • Education accounts

  • Trusts

  • Business partnerships, sole proprietorships, company, non-incorporated, restricted legal responsibility, restricted partnership, and funding membership

  • Margin accounts

  • Custodial accounts
  • HSAs
  • Annuities
  • Charitable

Investment selections

Stocks, ETFs, choices, mutual funds, bonds, CDs, annuities, and IPOs

Investment selections

Stocks, ETFs, choices, mutual funds, futures, foreign exchange, IPOs, and bonds

Account perks

  • Commission-free buying and selling
  • Automated and advisor-assisted investing
  • Active Trader Pro platform presents extra instruments and market sources for superior merchants
  • Zero-expense ratio funds
  • Stock and ETF screeners
  • Margin buying and selling
  • Socially accountable investing
  • Wealth administration
  • Retirement sources

Account perks

  • Commission-free buying and selling
  • Automated/managed portfolios
  • Advanced buying and selling platforms: thinkorswim internet, thinkorswim cell, and thinkorswim desktop
  • Tax-loss harvesting
  • Investment analysis and academic sources
  • Options statistics instruments, inventory scanners, and financial information out there
  • ETF screeners
  • 13,000+ mutual funds

Human advisors out there?

Yes — limitless entry to monetary teaching and funding administration with Fidelity Personalized Planning and Advice

Human advisors out there?

Yes — limitless entry to advisors with affiliated Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium account


Yes — Fidelity Go and Fidelity Personalized Planning and Advice


Yes — Schwab Intelligent Portfolios and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium affiliated accounts

Is Fidelity best for you?

Fidelity is an internet brokerage providing self-directed buying and selling accounts, automated investing accounts, IRAs and retirement accounts, wealth administration, and extra. 

And like many common funding platforms, you possibly can alternate shares, ETFs, and options with out commissions, and its self-directed brokerage accounts do not have a minimal requirement. Its choices contracts have a $0.65 payment, however many brokerages cost this quantity for choices contracts.

The brokerage primarily presents three totally different interfaces: its internet platform, Active Trader Pro interface, and its cell app. Active Trader Pro caters to superior customers trying to entry real-time market information and information and stronger buying and selling instruments multi function area.

Fidelity additionally presents a number of different funding sorts, together with bonds, CDs, cash market funds, annuities, IPOs, index funds, and mutual funds. In truth, it has greater than 10,000 funds, almost 3,400 of that are no-transaction payment mutual funds. It additionally presents expense ratio-free mutual funds (it calls these the Fidelity Flex mutual funds), and it makes use of these in its automated investing portfolios.

Its most simple robo-advisor, Fidelity Go, invests your cash into a personalised portfolio of the beforehand talked about mutual funds. There is not a minimal account measurement requirement to open this account, and Fidelity separates its payment schedule into three tiers: customers with balances underneath $10,000 pay $0 in charges, these with between $10,000 and $49,999 pay $3 per thirty days, and customers with $50,000 and above pay 0.35% per yr.

Its different automated investing account, Fidelity Personalized Planning & Advice, combines robo-advice with one-one-one monetary advisor steerage. However, this account has a $25,000 minimal requirement and a 0.50% advisory payment.

When it involves retirement accounts, Fidelity presents conventional IRAs, Roth IRAs, SEP IRAs, SIMPLE IRAs, Roth IRA for Kids, rollover IRAs, self-employed 401(okay)s, and Fidelity Advantage 401(okay)s. And in the event you’re in want of wealth administration, you possibly can make the most of one-on-one planning and funding administration by Fidelity Wealth Management. This service has a $250,000 minimal and 0.50 to 1.50% advisory payment.

Fidelity additionally supplies personal wealth administration, supplying you with entry to an entire workforce of Fidelity advisors. To qualify, you will must have a minimal of $2 million managed by Fidelity Wealth Services or Fidelity Strategic Disciplines and at the least $10 million in complete investable property.

Plus, learners or customers searching for extra information can make the most of a number of academic sources. For occasion, the brokerage has a Learning Center that comprises stay webinars, buying and selling and investing teaching classes, on-line courses, and skilled market insights. 

Read our Fidelity Investments review »

Is TD Ameritrade best for you?

TD Ameritrade funding account additionally presents commission-free buying and selling for shares, ETFs, and choices, with self-directed buying and selling, automated investing, and extra. Plus, its funding choice consists of futures, mutual funds, foreign exchange, bonds, CDs, over-the-counter crypto trusts, bitcoin futures, and annuities.

Like Fidelity, TD Ameritrade presents a platform particularly for superior, lively merchants: thinkorswim. But you will get extra out of thinkorswim than with the Fidelity equal. TD Ameritrade has thinkorswim internet, thinkorswim desktop, and thinkorswim cell platforms. Plus, these platforms provide an array of options, together with real-time market displays, earnings instruments, choices statistics, financial information, inventory scanners, and extra.

The brokerage additionally has a $0.65 choices contract payment, identical to Fidelity, however attributable to Charles Schwab’s acquisition, its automated investing accounts — Essential Portfolios, Selective Portfolios, and Personalized Portfolios — are now not out there to new shoppers. If you are a hands-off investor searching for robo-advice, you will should arrange an automatic account by its affiliate, Charles Schwab.

Charles Schwab presents two automated investing accounts: Schwab Intelligent Portfolios and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Premium. The former has a $5,000 minimal requirement and no advisory charges. It invests your cash into a personalised portfolio of ETFs and presents options like tax-loss harvesting, portfolio monitoring, and portfolio rebalancing. The latter account possibility provides in limitless CFP steerage. Like Fidelity Personalized Planning & Advice, it has a $25,000 minimal. But you will pay a $300 one-time planning payment a $30/month advisory payment.

On the retirement aspect, it supplies conventional IRAs, Roth IRAs, SEP IRAs, SIMPLE IRAs, solo 401(okay)s, and pension or revenue plans. And it presents greater than 13,000 mutual funds, with almost 3,700 of them being no-transaction-fee funds. Fidelity solely presents greater than 10,000 (solely about 3,400 of them are no-transaction-fee funds).

Plus, TD Ameritrade funding account has an in depth collection of academic sources. These embody webcasts and movies on totally different investing subjects, step-by-step market guides, and market information and analysis.

Read our TD Ameritrade review »

Fidelity vs. TD Ameritrade — Frequently requested questions (FAQ)

Is Fidelity or TD Ameritrade higher?

Fidelity and TD Ameritrade funding account each present self-directed buying and selling, IRAs, commission-free funding choices, academic sources, and extra.

But Fidelity is best for these searching for decrease charges and stronger automated investing choices. TD Ameritrade is a more sensible choice for mutual funds, futures, and superior buying and selling platforms.

How reliable is Fidelity?

The Better Business Bureau offers Fidelity Investments an A+ ranking to replicate its opinion of how properly the brokerage interacts with its prospects. In addition, Fidelity is registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and it presents as much as $500,000 in Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) insurance coverage.

Prospective customers ought to observe, nonetheless, that Fidelity paid $28.5 million in 2020 to settle a 2018 class-action lawsuit that alleged Fidelity didn’t uphold its fiduciary obligation by favoring its personal funding merchandise in the 401(okay) plan it provided. 

Can you belief TD Ameritrade?

TD Ameritrade has an A ranking with the Better Business Bureau, however since Charles Schwab acquired the brokerage in 2020, it is also essential to investigate Schwab’s background. The BBB offers Charles Schwab an A+. And like Fidelity, each TD Ameritrade and Charles Schwab are registered with the SEC, and the two platforms provide $500,000 SIPC insurance coverage.

Overall, Fidelity and TD Ameritrade seem to be reliable platforms, however you will additionally must conduct your individual analysis earlier than making a ultimate choice. 

Read the authentic article on Business Insider

Go to Source